Montero Bar & Grill - Best Brooklyn Guide 2025

Montero Bar & Grill

Directions

4.5 (360 reviews)

$
Bar Restaurant
Nautical-themed interior of Montero Bar & Grill with patrons enjoying drinks

Interior view of Montero Bar & Grill, showcasing its nautical theme

Order Online

Official website

Service options

Hours

Closed

monday2:00 PM - 2:00 AM
tuesday2:00 PM - 2:00 AM
wednesday2:00 PM - 2:00 AM
thursday2:00 PM - 2:00 AM
friday2:00 PM - 2:00 AM
saturday2:00 PM - 2:00 AM
sunday2:00 PM - 2:00 AM

Longtime watering hole with a weathered bar & pool table in a nautical-themed setting near Pier 6.

Ratings & Reviews

4.5
Overall

Review Sentiment

Positive
85%
Neutral
10%
Negative
5%

Based on 360 reviews

Popular Times

6AM
9AM
12PM
3PM
6PM
9PM
0AM

What People Mention

karaoke
63 mentions
atmosphere
15 mentions
pool table
12 mentions
prices
11 mentions
crowd
10 mentions
school (10) tv (4) bottle (4) jukebox (3) amethyst (2)

Questions & Answers

No questions and answers available for this location.

Highlights

    Detailed Guide

    Tucked along Brooklyn Heights' Atlantic Avenue, Montero Bar & Grill stands as a time capsule of the neighborhood’s seafaring legacy. Since 1939, this weathered mariner’s haunt has welcomed longshoremen, locals, and curious visitors with its unpretentious charm and nautical grit. Below its flickering neon sign lies a world of pool tables, karaoke nights, and walls steeped in maritime memorabilia[1][4][5].
    
    **A Living Relic of Brooklyn’s Waterfront**  
    Founded by Joseph and Antoinette Montero, the bar originally served dockworkers from nearby piers[4]. Today, its cloudy glass-block windows and wood-paneled interior still echo with tales of the harbor. Patrons sip beers beneath vintage ship wheels, fishing nets, and yellowed photos of regulars past—a collage of Brooklyn’s blue-collar soul[1][3][5].
    
    **Unfussy Vibes, Unforgettable Nights**  
    Thursdays through Saturdays, the bar transforms into a raucous karaoke hub where off-key renditions of Sinatra and Eminem blend with the clatter of pool balls[1][2]. Regulars praise the "old-school dive bar" energy, with one Tripadvisor reviewer noting it’s "the last of a kind" in a rapidly changing city[2][5]. The jukebox, stocked with classics, and Fourth of July parties add to its legend[5].
    
    **Why It’s a Must-Visit**  
    - **Late-Night Legacy**: Open until 4 AM daily, it’s a refuge for night owls[2].  
    - **Authenticity Over Trends**: No artisanal cocktails here—just cold beers, hearty pub fare, and zero pretense[2][3].  
    - **Historical Anchor**: Nominated for preservation by City Lore, it’s a living museum of Brooklyn’s working-class roots[5].  
    
    As high-rises encroach, Montero’s remains defiantly unchanged—a love letter to the borough’s salty, unpolished heart.  
    
    *73 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201 | Open daily from 2 PM - 4 AM[2][3].*
    

    Location

    Map location of 73 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201, Brooklyn, NY
    Map data ©2025 Google

    Explore Brooklyn Heights

    Explore more of what Brooklyn Heights has to offer.

    % Arabica

    % Arabica

    4.4 (1258)
    Cafes

    People Also Search For

    In Our Guide:

    The Brazen Head

    The Brazen Head

    4.4 (489)
    Bars

    Also Popular:

    Contact & Location

    73 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201, Brooklyn, NY

    Visit Website