Butler - Best Brooklyn Guide 2025

Butler

Directions

4.6 (658 reviews)

$10–20
Coffee shop Bakery Cafe Restaurant
Interior view of Butler cafe in Williamsburg with customers enjoying coffee

Cozy corner at Butler, a popular Williamsburg cafe

Order Online

Official website

Service options

Outdoor seatingDeliveryOnsite servicesTakeoutDine-in

Hours

Closed

monday6:30 AM - 5:00 PM
tuesday6:30 AM - 5:00 PM
wednesday6:30 AM - 5:00 PM
thursday6:30 AM - 5:00 PM
friday6:30 AM - 5:00 PM
saturday7:30 AM - 6:00 PM
sunday7:30 AM - 6:00 PM

Daytime cafe with a menu of breakfast, lunch & dessert items in a corner space.

Ratings & Reviews

4.6
Overall

Review Sentiment

Positive
85%
Neutral
10%
Negative
5%

Based on 658 reviews

Popular Times

6AM
9AM
12PM
3PM
6PM
9PM

What People Mention

pastries
76 mentions
sausage roll
17 mentions
breakfast sandwich
15 mentions
acai bowl
13 mentions
avocado toast
13 mentions
laptop (9) breakfast empanada (6) french toast (6) chocolate croissant (5) healthy (5)

Questions & Answers

No questions and answers available for this location.

Highlights

    Detailed Guide

    Butler has become a cornerstone of Williamsburg's daytime cafe culture, blending the warmth of a neighborhood bakery with the precision of specialty coffee. Tucked into a corner space at 95 S 5th St, this airy establishment draws crowds with its sunlit interiors featuring wooden tables, industrial-chic light fixtures, and an open kitchen where bakers craft flaky pastries in full view[1][3][4].

    Morning Rituals & Midday Comforts
    The menu shines brightest at breakfast with:

    • Everything cruffin – a croissant-muffin hybrid dusted with sesame and poppy seeds[5]
    • Triple chocolate croissants with Valrhona cocoa layers[5]
    • Savory breakfast sandwiches on house-baked biscuits[5]
    • Matcha lattes and oat milk cortados made with Intelligentsia beans[1][5]

    By lunch, the space fills with locals enjoying:

    • Hearty grain bowls topped with roasted vegetables
    • Open-faced tartines on sourdough
    • French toast drizzled with seasonal fruit compotes[5]

    Design & Vibe
    Hugo Murray's minimalist interior design lets natural light flood through large windows, while baristas craft drinks behind a marble counter. The South Williamsburg location offers full table service and outdoor seating – a rarity among NYC coffee shops[1][3]. Patrons often linger over laptops or books, drawn by the aroma of freshly ground coffee and the clatter of pastry trays being restocked[4].

    Need to Know
    Hours:
    6:30 AM–5 PM weekdays / 7:30 AM–6 PM weekends[1]
    Specialties: Gluten-free pastries, vegetarian breakfast options, and seasonal fruit galettes[5]
    Pro Tip: Arrive before 9 AM to snag the first batch of still-warm chocolate almond croissants[4][5].

    This cafe embodies Williamsburg's creative spirit – where quality ingredients meet laid-back sophistication, making every visit feel like discovering your new favorite corner table[1][4][5].

    Location

    Map location of 95 S 5th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249, Brooklyn, NY
    Map data ©2025 Google

    Explore Williamsburg

    Explore more of what Williamsburg has to offer.

    Cado Cafe

    Cado Cafe

    5.0 (9)
    Cafes
    mozaik cafe

    mozaik cafe

    5.0 (87)
    Cafes
    Muz Muz Shop & Cafè

    Muz Muz Shop & Cafè

    5.0 (327)
    Shopping

    People Also Search For

    In Our Guide:

    Black Brick Coffee

    Black Brick Coffee

    4.5 (569)
    Cafes

    Also Popular:

    Contact & Location

    95 S 5th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249, Brooklyn, NY

    Visit Website